In my kitchen right now, there is a loaf of bread, a box of crackers my kids demolish after school, and a bag of frozen berries for smoothies. Under the definition most researchers use, the bread and the crackers count as “ultra-processed.” The berries don’t. What’s surprising is that sugary products, like sodas and candy bars, are lumped into the same category as my whole-grain bread and flax crackers.
If you’re wondering about the credentials for this strange category, you’re asking the right question. The federal government is about to define parameters for what constitutes “ultra-processed foods”, and when it does, the fine print will matter more than the headline.
What actually happened
Here’s the timeline. In July 2025, the FDA and USDA put out a joint call for data, a formal Request for Information asking researchers, companies, and the public to help build a “uniform definition” of ultra-processed foods. The idea, the agencies said, was consistency: if everyone means the same thing by “ultra-processed,” research can actually be compared and policy can be built on it. More than 5,000 comments came in by the time the window closed on October 23, 2025.
Then, on August 10, 2026, HHS and USDA announced they’d sent a proposed definition to the White House budget office, the Office of Management and Budget (OMB), for final review. As of October 13, the text still hasn’t been released. OMB’s public calendar shows a string of meetings on the “White Paper: Proposed Definition of Ultra-Processed Food” running through September and into October 2026, some of the last formal chances to get data and perspective in front of decision-makers before it publishes.
What’s new: This is the first time the federal government has tried to put its own pin in what “ultra-processed” means.
What’s established: We’ve been arguing about the concept for more than 15 years without one.
As UNC food-policy researcher Lindsey Smith Taillie put it: “You have to know what it is that you’re intervening on.” A definition is the precondition for everything downstream, from school-meal rules to label warnings.
Why we don’t already have a definition
The system most researchers use today to determine degree of food processing is called NOVA. It was created by Brazilian researchers in 2009 and sorts food not by nutrients, but by how much it’s been altered. In NOVA’s world, “ultra-processed” roughly means products made with ingredients you’d never find in a home kitchen: certain preservatives, artificial flavors, highly refined sweeteners, and industrial formulations. It does not consider the nutritional content of the food, simply the ingredients.
NOVA was a breakthrough, and it also has a well-known flaw: it’s a very big category. As one recent analysis put it, it lumps a sugary soda in with fortified whole-grain bread, even though those foods aren’t nutritionally alike. Researchers have struggled to classify the same foods the same way twice, and a 2025 review found six different classification systems, each with its own criteria.
Dozens of observational studies link high ultra-processed food consumption to obesity, cardiovascular disease, and diabetes, but researchers still haven’t pinned down which ingredients, additives, or processing methods actually drive those associations, or at what exposure levels.
My favorite illustration of where the science stands comes from Kevin Hall, a senior investigator at the National Institutes of Health. Hall thought the whole ultra-processed concept was, in his words, “nonsense” and “anti-science.” He said so publicly in a debate with food writer Marion Nestle. So he ran the experiment to prove it.
Hall housed 20 adults at the NIH Clinical Center for four weeks. For the first two weeks, the subjects ate a diet of “ultra-processed” foods (using the NOVA definition), then they switched to a diet of unprocessed foods for the last two weeks. The diets were designed to have similar amounts of calories and key nutrients, and participants were told to eat as much as they wanted.
The result embarrassed the hypothesis: people ate more and gained weight on the ultra-processed menu. “This is the first study to demonstrate causality,” Hall said, “that ultra-processed foods cause people to eat too many calories and gain weight.”
Hall’s trial is the strongest evidence in the field. It’s also one small, short study. It tells us the effect is real without telling us exactly what causes it, which is precisely why the definition’s fine print matters so much. That’s the gap a federal definition is supposed to help close. HHS has described the goal as creating “a stronger foundation for future nutrition research.” Think of it as agreeing on the ruler before arguing about the measurement.
A white paper, not a rule: what’s the difference?
This is the part most coverage skips, and it’s the most important. The agencies have been clear: this is coming as a white paper, not a regulation. A white paper is the government thinking out loud on paper. It has no legal force. It doesn’t pull anything off shelves, change a label, or ban an ingredient.

Here’s an analogy: a white paper is a dictionary, and a rule is a speed limit. A dictionary doesn’t give you a ticket. But once everyone agrees on what a word means, it’s a lot easier to write the speed-limit sign.
And dictionaries get cited. As legal analysts at Greenberg Traurig noted this month, calling it research-focused “does not determine whether or how it may be used later in policymaking, regulatory activity, or litigation.” Once a federal definition exists, anyone can point to it: a state legislature writing a school-meals bill, a retailer setting procurement standards, a plaintiff’s attorney building a case. Whether it ever becomes enforceable is a separate decision the administration hasn’t made yet. But the definition becomes the benchmark everything else references.
That’s why the OMB meetings matter. They’re one of the last formal windows for input before the text locks.
The three dials that will decide everything
The entire fight comes down to what the definition keys on. Legal analysis describes three possible dials (processing methods, ingredients, nutrients, or some combination), and where the agencies set each one determines which foods land inside the category.
Dial 1: Processing methods
Does the definition care how the food was made? Extrusion, hydrogenation, industrial formulations you couldn’t replicate at home? This is NOVA’s home turf.
Dial 2: Ingredients
Does it flag what’s in it: specific additives, flavorings, colorings, preservatives? This is the most concrete dial, and the one industry watches closest, because an ingredient list is something you can reformulate around.
Dial 3: Nutrients
Does it weigh the food nutritionally? Added sugars, sodium, saturated fat? This dial looks the most like our existing nutrition labels, and it’s where a UPF definition could overlap, or collide, with everything from front-of-package labeling to dietary guidelines.
If you turn all three dials to the strictest setting, almost all items in grocery stores count as “ultra-processed”. And if you loosen up the dials, significantly fewer items qualify. The definition’s authors have to find the setting that’s scientifically defensible, and that’s the hard part, because the science hasn’t settled which dial matters most for health.
What’s already moving
Washington isn’t waiting in a vacuum. California passed a framework and directed rulemaking around a definition of UPFs. In the Senate, the Childhood Diabetes Reduction Act was introduced in August, and the Food Labeling Modernization Act was introduced in July and referred to committee. Neither uses the same criteria as the others. Add in state bills, enforcement activity, and private lawsuits, and you have at least three definitions that don’t agree with each other.
Industry, unsurprisingly, has opinions. The Consumer Brands Association, which represents companies like PepsiCo, Nestle, and Kraft Heinz, has cautioned that “any so-called definition that captures 80% of the nation’s food supply while picking winners and losers is fundamentally flawed,” in the words of spokesperson Rhonda Bentz. Bloomberg reported that CEOs and trade groups lobbied the White House to slow the white paper’s release, expressing concern that the research is not yet robust enough to inform policy, while a definition would increase costs and litigation.
Food-law attorney Alan Sachs told Food Ingredient’s Global Insights that because this is a white paper and not a regulation, the administration isn’t obligated to publish it by any date, or at all, and it could still be modified while under review.
Public-health groups are pushing the other way. “A federal definition would represent an important step toward strengthening the science that informs future nutrition policies and consumer choices. It is time to take that step,” said Dr. Mariell Jessup of the American Heart Association, one of the few public-health groups granted an OMB meeting so far.
Both sides understand the same thing: the dictionary gets written once, and then everybody has to use it.
What should you actually do with this news?
What’s key here for us as consumers is that the definition won’t tell you what’s healthy. It will tell you what counts, and then the arguing about what to do with the count begins. You’ll still need to remember that everything is better in moderation.
And you will still need to remember to include five to seven servings of fruits and vegetables, eat 25-30 grams of fiber, eat a minimum of 0.85 grams per pound of ideal body weight, and healthy fats.
Nothing in your cart needs to change today. I pack my five-year-old’s lunch most mornings, and I’ll pack it the same way next week. This definition won’t make any food illegal, and it won’t, by itself, change a single label or my understanding of proper balance nutrition.
But here’s the proportionate take: definitions are infrastructure.
A UPF definition is the shared language that may let researchers compare studies, could allow SNAP and school-meal programs to write rules that mean the same thing in every state, and may let labeling debates argue about policy instead of arguing about the dictionary.
What’s new is that the federal government is finally writing that dictionary entry. What’s established is that the science underneath it is still catching up. We know that observational studies have shown dietary patterns high in ultra-processed foods may be associated with real health risks, but we don’t yet know precisely which dials to turn.
Watch two things when the text drops: which of the three dials — processing, ingredients, nutrients — does the most work, and who cites it first. The first tells you how scientific the definition is trying to be. The second tells you how political it’s about to become.











The researchers found significant improvements in intelligence, attention, concentration, and memory, although they did not find sufficient evidence of improved school achievement. Effects varied among studies and should not be interpreted to mean that iron supplements enhance cognition in every child.
A struggling student does not announce, “My iron stores are low,” or “My diet lacks sufficient variety.” Instead, the difficulty may sound like: “I’m tired.” “I can’t think.” “I forgot.” “This is too hard.” “I don’t care.”




The same applies to richer, more calorie-dense meals. Pasta, creamy dishes, cheese-heavy meals, and restaurant dining are not “off-plan” they’re part of how people actually live. But when they become routine, they start to crowd out simpler, more nutrient-dense meals built around protein and vegetables. A bowl of pasta on a Friday night, pizza with friends, or dinner out can absolutely fit into a healthy pattern. What matters is that these meals are part of the week, not the structure of every day.




Fluid naturally moves out of tiny blood vessels and into surrounding tissues to transport oxygen, nutrients, and signaling molecules to reach cells. Scientists call this process filtration, and it happens constantly as part of healthy circulation.















76 adults with low vitamin D consume tomato soup daily for three weeks, each serving made from tomatoes edited to accumulate provitamin D3, which converts in the body to vitamin D3.



While still true, these guidelines often fail to capture the complexity of human biology—and the individuality of how we metabolize food.
Emerging platforms 
Samsung Food’s Vision AI easily scanned items in my fridge, sometimes correctly identifying even partially used produce, and generated recipes that incorporated what I already had on hand. It wasn’t perfect (a few mystery leftovers stumped it), but the suggestions often saved me from another night of takeout.













Fine particles, smaller than 2.5 microns, can penetrate deep into the lungs and potentially enter the bloodstream, causing low-grade inflammation and oxidative stress. These processes are thought to aggravate or even drive chronic diseases.
A study by the 









But many of us may be accidentally sending our hormones the wrong instructions. According to the
Produced by the pancreas, it responds to carbohydrates by clearing sugar from the blood and directing it to be stored or used for energy.

“



Advocates claim it reduces inflammation, improves mental clarity, and helps manage glucose levels, and promotes weight loss. However, the reported benefits of this diet are more anecdotal than clinical. In fact, multiple studies cite the dangers of this diet, including 
For instance, high consumption of saturated fats like beef tallow – which
Yes, ACV can slightly
Experts generally agree that most people, especially women and older adults, 


During the 2022 E. coli outbreak in leafy greens, 


This allows agencies to prioritize inspections based on actual risk, not just routine schedules.

General Mills has teamed up with 
This isn’t just about cooking with oil. It’s part of a broader philosophical divide. As institutional trust declines, many are turning to tradition and nature for guidance—assuming, sometimes wrongly, that these values offer more than modern science.


The Thin Mint headlines may be new, but glyphosate conversations are years old.
Both the
It’s also important to rinse all

Brands like 

It doesn’t just kill weeds; it kills anything green, including farm crops such as corn, soybeans, cotton, canola, sugar beets, and alfalfa. These crops have all been genetically modified so that the farmer can spray glyphosate after the crop emerges from the ground and kill the weeds, but not the crop.

While there were different views on its effect on soil health, all agreed that it is the least toxic of the herbicides on the market.
One farmer invented



The FDA’s decision to act on Red Dye No. 3 after decades of inaction may signal a shift towards more proactive regulation of food additives.
There are many substitutes for Red Dye No. 3, such as beet juice, purple sweet potato extract, red cabbage extract, carmine, and pomegranate juice. These natural substitutes align with growing consumer preferences for clean-label ingredients. After all, many of us would rather consume pomegranate juice in Jell-o than red dye.



Peter Attia, MD, who wrote Outlive: The Science and Art of Longevity, points to VO2 max as the best predictor of longevity.

Hanging from a bar measures your grip strength, which measures your overall muscle ratio – a good indicator of overall fitness.

Spinach: 

Sustainability is no longer a buzzword but a mandate. 






This vitamin is essential for a healthy body, as it helps develop red blood cells,








All-natural 






While protein can help you feel full and satisfied, consuming more protein than your body needs doesn’t magically become muscle…





They’re found in almost every culture and cuisine. Historians 

























Dental benefits
Glycemic control


























For heart health, it champions the consumption of
It is not that those ingredients are bad for you, but you want to look for foods that have more healthy nutritious ingredients that add value to your body. The report also points to a burgeoning interest in traditional and 
































Let’s briefly examine just some of the ways the Belief Effect impacts overall health.








Good news for you, most people already consume more than double the recommended amount, typically 900-1000 milligrams daily as part of their regular diets. Some tryptophan-dense foods are cod, spirulina, nuts and seeds, and legumes.
Not sure how to tell the difference between a complex carb and a simple carb? Here’s a good trick: most whole, unprocessed foods contain complex carbs. Avoid processed foods and “white” foods, which are mostly comprised of simple carbs.


















But should you really be afraid of these “Dirty Dozen” items?

It has been shown to inhibit the release of histamine from immune cells, such as mast cells and basophils, which may help reduce
Bromelain is a mixture of enzymes found in pineapple stems. Yes, pineapple stems. Really the only way to naturally get bromelain is through fresh pineapple juice. However, bromelain supplements can provide concentrated doses of the enzyme.
Citrus fruits are dense in potent
While omega 3s can 








Remember that the grams listed next to the nutritional fact are per serving size. Furthermore, the percentage to the right details what percentage of the recommended daily value (DV) each serving size contains.














Probably the most common source we hear about for heavy metals in everyday foods is mercury in larger fish, like swordfish, shark, and the ever-popular tuna.






While the label is currently voluntary, many national health authorities have adopted it, including France, Belgium, Spain, Germany, Switzerland, the Netherlands, and most recently, Luxembourg.







What happened? After seriously overthinking this, basically, we were…fine. We had plenty of energy to work out, we were not tired and while we were hungry, we weren’t “hangry”, so the entire five-day period was only modestly unpleasant. Although, I was very excited to eat a ‘real meal’ on day six!